The News & Record (Greensboro, N.C.)
July 12, 2005
Editorial: Auditor Questions Pork-Barrel Spending
North Carolina's legislative leaders
control millions of dollars in "reserve funds," which
they parcel out according to their own whims.
That isn't news. The General Assembly has operated like
that for many years.
What did make news recently -- at least on inside pages
of many newspapers -- was state Auditor Les Merritt's
report about legislative spending practices and his
forwarding of the document to N.C. Attorney General Roy
Cooper for his review.
This overdue official attention finally addresses the
question of whether the principle of checks and balances
applies to the legislative branch of state government.
Merritt looked at how $14 million in designated reserve
funds were allocated during the 2004 General Assembly
session. The state budget approved for the 2004-2005
fiscal year authorized legislative leaders Marc Basnight,
Jim Black and Richard Morgan to decide how that money
should be spent.
"The limited time in which the budget was finalized,
printed and then voted on by the legislature limited
budget transparency, especially as related to the
Reserve Funds," the auditor wrote.
In other words, most legislators had little idea where
the money was going.
It ended up as "pork barrel," the term given to spending
often intended to serve political as well as public
purposes.
Organizations receiving funds may provide worthwhile
services, but as the auditor noted, there's no
application process that treats everyone equally.
Funding occurs solely at the discretion of a few
legislators.
In some instances, that may violate the law, the audit
report implies, citing a statute titled "No expenditure
for purposes for which the General Assembly has
considered but not enacted an appropriation." Which
means: If the legislature has said no, someone else
isn't allowed to say yes.
The auditor noted that legislative leaders direct
executive agencies how to spend this pork-barrel money.
The report detailed the process by which House Speaker
Jim Black's staff initiated creation of a job in the
Department of Cultural Resources for former legislative
ally Michael Decker and provided the funding for his
salary.
The auditor suggested that Cooper might want to consider
whether separation-of-power issues are raised in
relation to the allocation and control of reserve funds.
Executive agencies are run by the governor. So, why are
legislative leaders telling them what jobs they should
create and whom they should hire?
Maybe the attorney general will leave these questions
alone. He depends on the legislature to provide his own
budget. But it's worthwhile to ask how much power one
branch of government should have and how much of that
power should be exercised by just a few individuals.
|